MERCY
by Andrea Dworkin
Copyright © 1990, 1991 by Andrea
Dworkin.
All rights reserved.
Excerpt from Chapter Nine
In October 1972 (Age 27)
I can't even close my eyes now frankly but I think it's because
I'm this whatever it is, you can have sophisticated words for it
but the fact is you can be sleeping inside with everything
locked and they get in and do it to you no matter how bad it
hurts. In magazines they say women's got allure, or so they call
it, but it's more like being some dumb wriggling thing that God
holds out before them on a stick with a string, a fisher of men.
The allure's there even if you got open sores on you; I know.
The formal writing problem, frankly, is that the bait can't
write the story. The bait ain't even barely alive. There's a
weird German tradition that the fish turned the tables and
rewrote the story to punish the fisherman but you know it's a
lie and it's some writer of fiction being what became known as a
modernist but before that was called outright a smartass; and
the fish still ain't bait unless it's eviscerated and bleeding.
I just can't risk it now but if I was a man I could close my
eyes, I'm sure; at night, I'd close them, I'm sure. I don't
think my hands would shake. I don't think so; or not so much; or
not all the time; or not without reason; there's no reason now
anyone can see. My breasts wouldn't bleed as if God put a sign
on me; blessing or curse, it draws flies. Tears of blood fall
from them; they weep blood for me, because I'm whatever it is:
the girl, as they say politely; the girl. You're supposed to
make things up for books but I am afraid to make things up
because in life everything evaporates, it's gone in mist, just
disappears, there's no sign left, except on you, and you are a
fucking invisible ghost, they look right through you, you can
have bruises so bad the skin's pulled off you and they don't see
nothing; you bet women had the vapors, still fucking do, it
means it all goes away in the air, whatever happened, whatever
he did and however he did it, and you're left feeling sick and
weak and no one's going to say why; it's just women, they faint
all the time, they're sick all the time, fragile things,
delicate things, delicate like the best punching bags you ever
seen. They say it's lies even if they just did it, or maybe
especially then. I don't know really. There's nothing to it, no
one ever heard of it before or ever saw it or not here or not
now; in all history it never happened, or if it happened it was
the Nazis, the exact, particular Nazis in Germany in the
thirties and forties, the literal Nazis in uniform; when they
were out of uniform they were just guys, you know, they loved
their families, they paid off their whores, just regular guys.
No one else ever did anything, certainly no one now in this fine
world we have here; certainly not the things I think happened,
although I don't know what to call them in any serious way. You
just crawl into a cave of silence and die; why are there no
great women artists? Some people got nerve. Blood on cement,
which is all we got in my experience, ain't esthetic, although I
think boys some day will do very well with it; they'll put it in
museums and get a fine price. Won't be their blood. It would be
some cunt's they whispered to the night before; a girl; and then
it'd be art, you see; or you could put it on walls, make murals,
be political, a democratic art outside the museums for the
people, Diego Rivera without any conscience whatsoever instead
of the very tenuous one he had with respect to women, and then
it'd be extremely major for all the radicals who would discover
the expressive value of someone else's blood and I want to tell
you they'd stop making paint but such things do not happen and
such things cannot occur, any more than the rape so-called can
happen or occur or the being beaten so bad can happen or occur
and there are no words for what cannot happen or occur and if
you think something happened or occurred and there are no words
for it you are at a dead end. There's nothing where they force
you; there's nothing where you hurt so much; there's nothing
where it matters, there's nothing like it anywhere. So it
doesn't feel right to make things up, as you must do to write
fiction, to lie, to elaborate, to elongate, to exaggerate, to
distort, to get tangled up in moderations or modifications or
deviations or compromises of mixing this with that or combining
this one with that one because the problem is finding words for
the truth, especially if no one will believe it, and they will
not. I can't make things up because I wouldn't know after a
while what's blood, what's ink. I barely know any words for what
happened to me yesterday, which doesn't make tomorrow something
I can conceive of in my mind; I mean words I say to myself in my
own head; not social words you use to explain to someone else. I
barely know anything and if I deviate I am lost; I have to be
literal, if I can remember, which mostly I cannot. No one will
acknowledge that some things happen and probably at this point
in time there is no way to say they do in a broad sweep; you
describe the man forcing you but you can't say he forced you. If
I was a man I could probably say it; I could say I did it and
everyone would think I made it up even though I'd just be
remembering what I did last night or twenty minutes ago or once,
long ago, but it probably wouldn't matter. The rapist has words,
even though there's no rapist, he just keeps inventing rape; in
his mind; sure. He remembers, even though it never happened;
it's fine fiction when he writes it down. Whereas my mind is
getting worn away; it's being eroded, experience keeps washing
over it and there's no sea wall of words to keep it intact, to
keep it from being washed away, carried out to sea, layer by
layer, fine grains washed away, a thin surface washed away, then
some more, washed away. I am fairly worn away in my mind, washed
out to sea. It probably doesn't matter anyway. People lead their
little lives. There's not much dignity to go around. There's
lies in abundance, and silence for girls who don't tell them. I
don't want to tell them. A lie's for when he's on top of you and
you got to survive him being there until he goes; Malcolm X
tried to stop saying a certain lie, and maybe I should change
from Andrea because it's a lie. It's just that it's a precious
thing from my mother that she tried to give me; she didn't want
it to be such an awful lie, I don't think. So I have to be the
writer she tried to be -- Andrea; not-cunt -- only I have to do
it so it ain't a lie. I ain't fabricating stories. I'm making a
different kind of story. I'm writing as truthful as the man with
his fingers, if only I can remember and say; but I ain't on his
side. I'm on some different side. I'm telling the truth but from
a different angle. I'm the one he done it to. The bait's
talking, honey, if she can find the words and stay even barely
alive, or even just keep the blood running; it can't dry up, it
can't rot. The bait's spilling the beans. The bait's going to
transcend the material conditions of her situation, fuck you
very much, Mr. Marx. The bait's going way past Marx. The bait's
taking her eviscerated, bleeding self and she ain't putting it
back together, darling, because, frankly, she don't know how;
the bait's a realist, babe, the bait's no fool, she's just going
to bleed all over you and you are going to have to find the
words to describe the stain, a stain as big as her real life,
boy; a big, nasty stain; a stain all over you, all the blood you
ever spilled; that's the esthetic dimension, through art she
replicates the others you done it to, gets the stain to
incorporate them too. It's coming right back on you, sink or
swim; fucking drown your head in it; give in, darling; go down.
That's the plan, in formal terms. The bait's got a theory; the
bait's finding a practice, working it out; the bait's going to
write it down and she don't have to use words, she'll make
signs, in blood, she's good at bleeding, boys, the vein's open,
boys, the bait's got plenty, each month more and more without
dying for a certain long period of her life, she can lose it or
use it, she works in broad strokes, she makes big gestures, big
signs; oh and honey there's so much bait around that there's
going to be a bloodbath in the old town tonight, when the new
art gets its start. You are going to be sitting in it; the new
novel; participation, it's called; I'm smearing it all over you.
It ain't going to be made up; it ain't going to be a lie; and
you are going to pay attention, directly, even though it's by a
girl, because this time it's on you. If I find a word, I'll use
it; but I ain't waiting, darling, I already waited too long. If
you was raised a boy you don't know how to get blood off, you're
shocked, surprised, in Vietnam when you see it for the first
time and I been bleeding since I was nine, I'm used to putting
my hands in it and I live. You don't give us no words
for what's true so now there's signs, a new civilization just
starting now: her name's not-cunt and she's just got to express
herself, say some this and that, use what's there, take what's
hers: her blood's hers; your blood's hers. Here's the difference
between us, sweet ass: I'm using blood you already spilled;
mine; hers; cunt's. I ain't so dirty as to take yours. I don't
confuse this new manifesto with being Artaud; he was on the
other side. There are sides. If he spills my blood, it's art. If
I put mine on him, it's deeply not nice or good or, as they say,
interesting; it's not interesting. There's a certain -- shall we
understate? -- distaste. It's bad manners but not rude in an
artistically valid sense. It's just not being the right kind of
girl. It's deranged but not in the Rimbaud sense. It's just not
being Marjorie Morningstar, which is the height to which you may
aspire, failed artist but eventually fine homemaker. It's loony,
yes, it's got some hate in it somewhere, but it ain't
revolutionary like Sade who spilled blood with style; perhaps
they think a girl can't have style but since a girl can't really
have anything else I think I can pull it off; me and the other
bait; there's many styles of allure around. Huey Newton's my
friend and I send ten percent of any money I have to the Black
Panthers instead of paying taxes because they're still bombing
the fucking Vietnamese, if you can believe it. He sends me poems
and letters of encouragement. I write him letters of
encouragement. I'm afraid to show him any of my pages I wrote
because perhaps he's not entirely cognizant of the problems,
esthetic and political, I face. I look for signs in the press
for if he's decent to women but there's not too much to see;
except you have to feel some distrust. He's leading the
revolution right now and I think the bait's got to have a place
in it. I am saying to him that women too got to be whole; and
old people cared for; and children educated and fed; and women
not raped; I say, not raped; I say it to him, not raped. He's
saying the same thing back to me in his letters, except for the
women part. He is very Mao in his poem style, because it helps
him to say what he knows and gives him authority, I can see
that, it makes his simple language look strong and purposeful,
not as if he's not too educated. It's brilliant for that whereas
I am more lost; I can't cover up that I don't have words. I
can't tell if raped is a word he knows or not; if he
thinks I am stupid to use it or not; if he thinks it exists or
not; because we are polite and formal and encouraging to each
other and he doesn't say. I am working my part out. He is taking
care of the big, overall picture, the big needs, the great
thrust forward. I am in a fine fit of rebellion and melancholy
and I think there's a lot that's possible so I am in a passion
of revolutionary fire with a new esthetic boiling in me, except
for my terrible times. The new esthetic started out in ignorance
and ignominy, in sadness, in forgetting; it pushed past sadness
into an overt rebellion -- tear this down, tear this apart --
and it went on to create: it said, we'll learn to write without
words and if it happened we will find a way to say so and if it
happened to us it happened. For instance, if it happened to me
it happened; but I don't have enough confidence for that,
really, because maybe I'm wrong, or maybe it's not true, or how
do you say it, but if it happened to us, to us, you know, the
ones of us that's the bait, then it happened. It happened. And
if it happened, it happened. We will say so. We will find a way
to say so. We will take the blood that was spilled and smear it
in public ways so it's art and politics and science; the
fisherman won't like the book so what's new; he'll say it ain't
art or he'll say it's bullshit; but here's the startling part;
the bait's got a secret system of communication, not because
it's hidden but because the fisherman's fucking stupid; so
arrogant; so sure of forever and a day; so sure he don't listen
and he don't look and he says it ain't anything and he thinks
that means it ain't anything whereas what it means is that we
finally can invent a new alphabet first, big letters, proud, new
letters from which will come new words for old things, real
things, and the bait says what they are and what they mean, and
then we get new novels in which the goal is to tell the truth
deep truth. So make it all up, the whole new thing, to be able
to say what's there; because they are keeping it hidden now.
You're not supposed to write something down that happened;
you're supposed to invent. We'll write down what happened and
invent the personhood of who it happened to; we'll make a
language for her so we can tell a story for her in which she
will see what happened and know for sure it happened and it
mattered; and the boys will have to confront a new esthetic that
tells them to go suck eggs I am for this idea; energized by it.
It's clear that if you need the fisherman to read the book --
his critical appreciation as it were -- this new art ain't for
you. If he's got what he did to you written on him or close
enough to him, rude enough near him, is he different, will he
know? I say he'll have to know; it's the brilliance of the
medium -- he's it, the vehicle of political and cultural
transcendence as it were It's a new, forthright communication --
they took the words but they left your arm, your hand, so far at
least; it could change, but for now; he's the living canvas; he
can refuse to understand but he cannot avoid knowing; it's your
blood, he spilled it, you've used it on him It's a simplicity
Artaud failed, frankly, to achieve. We'll make it new; epater
the fuckers. Then he can be human or not; he's got a choice,
which is more than he ever gave; he can put on the uniform,
honest, literal Nazi, or not. The clue is to see what you don't
have as the starting place and you look at it straight and you
say what does it give me, not what does it take; you say what do
I have and what don't I have and am I making certain
presumptions about what I need that are in fact their
presumptions, so much garbage in my way, and if I got rid of the
garbage what then would I see and could I use it and how; and
when. I got hope. I got faith. I see it falling. I see it
ending. I see it bent over and hitting the ground. And, what's
even better is that because the fisherman ain't going to listen
as if his life depended on it we got a system of secret
communication so foolproof no scoundrel could imagine it, so
perfect, so pure; the less we are, the more we have; the less we
matter, the more chance we get; the less they care, the more
freedom is ours; the less, the more, you see, is the basic
principle, it's like psychological jujitsu except applied to
politics through a shocking esthetic; you use their fucking
ignorance against them; ignorance is a synonym in such a
situation for arrogance and arrogance is tonnage and in jujitsu
you use your opponent's weight against him and you do it if
you're weak or poor too, because it's all you have; and if
someone doesn't know you're human they're a Goddamn fool and
they got a load of ignorance to tip them over with. You ain't
got literature but you got a chance; a chance; you
understand -- a chance; you got a chance because the bait's
going to get it, and there's going to be a lot of wriggling
things jumping off God's stick. I live in this real fine, sturdy
tenement building made out of old stone. They used to have
immigrants sleeping in the hallways for a few pennies a night so
all the toilets are out there in the halls. They had them
stacked at night; men sleeping on top of each other and women
selling it or not having a choice; tenement prostitution they
call it in books, how the men piled in the halls to sleep but
the women had to keep putting out for money for food. They did
it standing up. Now you walk through the hall hoping there's no
motherfucker with a knife waiting for you, especially in the
toilets, and if you have to pee, you are scared, and if you have
to shit, it is fully frightening. I go with a knife in my hand
always and I sleep with a knife under my pillow, always. I have
not had a shit not carrying a knife since I came here. I got a
bank account. I am doing typing for stupid people. I don't like
to make margins but they want margins. I think it's better if
each line's different, if it flows like a poem, if it's uneven
and surprising and esthetically nice. But they want it like it's
for soldiers or zombies, everything lined up, left and right,
with hyphens breaking words open in just the right places, which
I don't know where they are. I type, I steal but less now,
really as little as possible though I will go to waitress hell
for stealing tips, I know that, I will be a prisoner in a circle
of hell and they will put the faces of all the waitresses around
me and all their shabby, hard lives that I made worse, but
stealing tips is easy and I am good at it as I have been since
childhood and when I have any money in my pocket I do truly
leave great chunks of it and when I am older and rich I will be
profligate and if I ever go broke in my old days it will be from
making it up to every waitress alive in the world then, but this
generation's getting fucked unavoidably. Someday I will write a
great book with the lines moving like waves in the sea, flowing
as much as I want them. I'm Andrea is what I will find a deep
way to express in honor of my mama who thought it up; a
visionary, though the vision couldn't withstand what the man did
to me early; or later, the man, in the political sense.
Go to NEXT CHAPTER: "April 30, 1974
(Age 27)"
Return to MERCY TABLE OF
CONTENTS
|